TopTenREVIEWS - Gold Award - Awarded for excellence in design, usability and feature set

As one of the sites to pioneer photo books, Shutterfly still holds a strong presence in the industry because the company provides a product that combines both usability and quality. The online photo editor is appealing to both experts and beginners with its range of features and its easy-to-use interface. Shutterfly earns our Top Ten Reviews Gold Award because of its wide variety of features that help you create the best photo book for any occasion.

Quality & Services
Compare
10/10
Shutterfly
Mixbook
Snapfish
Walmart Photo
AdoramaPix
Walgreens Photo
Picaboo
Blurb
MyCanvas
PrestoPhoto
10
9.8
9.5
9.4
9
8.3
8.8
8.3
8.8
7.5

Shutterfly offers more than 245 templates, which is far more than other photo book publishers. Using these templates, you can add personality and embellishments to your photos. With such variety, you are likely to find the exact style you are looking for.

There are two different ways to create a photo book, and each appeals to a different skill level: You can choose the Simple Path or the Custom Path. The Simple Path automatically arranges your photos in your chosen template and is perfect for beginners, as it requires minimal effort; however, the designs and page layouts are basic with few design elements on them. The Custom Path allows for more creative license. You can design your own layouts, adjust and edit photos, add embellishments, and add text. Using the Custom Path, you can also add predesigned professional layouts to your custom photo book. If your skill level falls somewhere in the middle, you can alternate between the two different methods.

The online book editor includes several tools to help you create a photo book using the Custom Path. You can easily change the theme and background of your project or add text boxes, images, embellishments and additional pages. You can even edit the photos you are using with the online editor. It has features that reduce red eye, rotate an image and change or enhance the colors in a picture. The editor also identifies low-resolution images, giving you the chance to either resize or remove the picture.

This service provides you with several different ways to share your photos. With online storage, you can save, share or add photos to your photo book at any time. At any point during the project, you can share your photo book by adding it to a share site, Facebook, Blogger or by just emailing it to friends. You can also export the project as a PDF file and print it anywhere you want. 

Shutterfly’s high standard of quality is evident in its finished products. The durable books feature a sturdy spine that supports the pages and protects the precious memories inside. The customizable cover can feature your favorite image, and you can choose the template you want to use for the cover. The pages are printed on photo paper, and the pictures are crisp and clear. You have the option of choosing glossy, matte and standard photo finishes, but anything above standard costs extra. The processing time to create your photo book ranges from one to three business days.

Book Options
Compare
10/10
Shutterfly
Mixbook
Snapfish
Walmart Photo
AdoramaPix
Walgreens Photo
Picaboo
Blurb
MyCanvas
PrestoPhoto
10
9.6
9.8
9.8
8.8
9.8
8.5
8.8
8.1
9.4

Shutterfly offers several different sizing and cover options for its photo books. Seven sizes are available: 5 x 7, 7 x 9, 8 x 8, 8 x 11, 10 x 10, 12 x 12 and 11 x 14 inches. These are among the most common sizing options for photo books. Shutterfly also provides 12 different cover options that add variety to your custom photo book. You can give your photo book a hard cover, soft cover, hard cover with matte finish, padded photo cover or a cover with die-cut windows in either cloth, linen, leather or crushed silk.

Album Creation
Compare
9.8/10
Shutterfly
Mixbook
Snapfish
Walmart Photo
AdoramaPix
Walgreens Photo
Picaboo
Blurb
MyCanvas
PrestoPhoto
9.8
10
9.8
9.4
9.8
8.8
9.4
9.8
9.4
6.3

The interface is organized and clearly labeled. If you don’t know what a button does, you can easily find out by hovering over it with your mouse. Uploading photos and editing pages is easy. You can upload photos from your computer, Facebook, Instagram and several other sources right to the photo book editor.

When you are ready to order your photo book, the site provides a preview that displays the book in high resolution, so you know what it will look like when it prints. If you find any errors, you can easily return to editing mode and fix the book.

Support & Shipping
Compare
9.6/10
Shutterfly
Mixbook
Snapfish
Walmart Photo
AdoramaPix
Walgreens Photo
Picaboo
Blurb
MyCanvas
PrestoPhoto
9.6
9.4
9.4
8.8
8.8
9.4
9.4
8.1
7.5
8.1

Shutterfly provides support for all of its services. You'll find a telephone number, email address and live chat feature to contact technical support for any problems that come up while making your photo book. However, the operating hours for the phone are limited, so if you need to contact support, email and live chat are the best options. The company also provides a searchable FAQs database, so you can explore topics and find answers to your questions. Additionally, there is a user forum where you can exchange ideas and solutions.

There are several different shipping methods. However, with processing time the expedited shipping option still takes almost a week. If you want the most economic option, allow for two weeks of processing and shipping to ensure you get your order in time.

Shutterfly Summary:
9.9/10

Shutterfly makes creating a photo book easy. You decide how much control you want over the design process. Whichever path you choose, you can create a high-quality photo book with crisp images and vivid graphics. All of this combines to make Shutterfly the best photo book service available.

By
 
 
 

Shutterfly

Pros
Shutterfly offers the largest selection of templates, backgrounds and embellishments.

Cons
The telephone support line has limited hours of operation.

The Verdict:
 9.93/10

Shutterfly’s online photo editor is easy to navigate, and with the multitude of options and add-ons available, just about anyone can create a professional-looking photo book.